New York

    Freshwater

    Lake George Hoax

  1. 1934-05-03 Monsters, faked and otherwise Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, AB), p. 4
  2. 1934-05-03 A monster that once was a headliner Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, AB), p. 4
  3. 1934-05-03 Try a pet Sea -Serpent Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, AB), p. 4

    ————————

  4. 1940-05-13 Artist dies The Albertan (Calgary, AB), p. 3

  5. 1971-05-25 It came from beneath the river St. Albans Daily Messenger (St. Albans, VT), p. 7

    Mud Lake, Jefferson County

  6. 1931-03-05 No title The Gazette (Montreal, QC), p. 14

    ————————————————————

    Batavia Monster

  7. 1960-08-02 'Monster' subject of Batavia hunt The Kingston Daily Freeman (Kingston, NY), p. 2
  8. 1960-08-02 Batavia seeks 'monster' The Ithaca Journal (Ithaca, NY), p. 1

  9. 1960-08-03 Footprints fail to fool Democrat and Chronicle (Rochester, NY), p. 18

  10. 1960-08-04 'Monster' shuns eain Buffalo Courier Express (Buffalo, NY), p. 21

    ————————————————————

    Long Island Mystery Creature

  11. 1932-03-27 "It" mystifies Long Islanders The Spokesman-Review (Spokane, WA), p. 8
  12. 1932-03-27 "It" mystifies Long Islanders The Spokesman-Review (Spokane, WA), p. 8

    ————————

    Loch Sheldrake

  13. 1984-08-04 Second New York lake may have a 'monster' The Gazette (Montreal, QC), p. G10

    ————————

    Long Island Mystery Bird

  14. 1934-07-04 A monster of the air The Manchester Guardian (London, ENG), p. 10
  15. 1934-07-19 Those monsters The Ottawa Evening Journal (Ottawa, ON), p. 6

    ————————

  16. 1934-06-21 2 Douglaston Owls Shot Down By H. S. Nimrods, 3d Escapes Brooklyn Times Union (Brooklyn, NY), p. 6A

  17. 1934-07-19 A British! Explanation of the Long Island mystery bird [Part 1] [Part 2] Waterloo Daily Courier (Waterloo, IA), p. 4

  18. 1934-07-20 [Part 1] [Part 2] Saskatoon Star-Phoenix (Saskatoon, SK), p. 11

  19. 1934-07-21 Monsters for everybody [Part 1] [Part 2] The Vancouver Daily Province (Vancouver, BC), p. 6

    ————————

    Cardboard Headed, Headless Cat

  20. 1911-03-30 Blame ghost Cat for hotel scare Trenton Evening Times (Trenton, NJ) , p. 12 Newspapers.com NewspaperARCHIVE
  21. 1911-04-21 Ghost Cat is blamed [Part 1] [Part 2] The Evening Record (Hackensack, NJ) , pp. 1 & 2

    ————————

    Kinderhook Creature

  22. 1976-08-27 Hairy monsters or little green men? Whitehall folk aim to find out which Rutland Daily Herald (Rutland, VT), p. 4

    ————————

    ————————————————————

    Marine

    Angler Fish

  23. 1947-08-07 Sea monster is brought home to prove story The Greenfield Daily Reporter (Greenfield, IN), p. 8

    Cape Lookout

  24. 1947-12-31 Ship strikes "sea monster" in Atlantic; captain tells story The Palladium-Item (Richmond, IN), p. 1

    Lightship Ambrose

  25. 1946-12-16 Is this a cousin of B.C.'s Ogopogo? The Leader-Post (Regina, SK), p. 3
  26. 1946-12-23 Is this a cousin of B.C.'s Ogopogo? Edmonton Bulletin (Edmonton, AB), p. 10
  27. 1946-12-23 Is this a cousin of B.C.'s Ogopogo? Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, AB), p. 8

    ————————————————————

    Hominid

  28. 1891-04-06 They think it is the Devil Alexandria Gazette (Alexandria, VA), p. 1

    Amityville Ape

    Amityville, Long Island

  29. 1934-09-09 World in Review — This and that The Boston Herald (Boston, MA), p. 7A

    ————————————————————

    Cougar

  30. 2005-03-26 Cougar sightings create stir [Part 1] [Part 2] Star-Gazette, New York Edition (Elmira, NY), pp. 1A & 5A
  31. 2005-03-26 Cougar sightings create stir - Part 1 Star-Gazette, Penn-Waverly Edition (Elmira, NY), p. 1A

  32. 2005-03-26 'It was definitely a cat' spotter says Star-Gazette, New York Edition (Elmira, NY), p. 5A
  33. 2005-03-26 'It was definitely a cat' spotter says Star-Gazette, Penn-Waverly Edition (Elmira, NY), p. 1A

    ————————

  34. 2001-02-04 Have you seen me lately? Rochester Democrat and Chronicle (Rochester, NY), p. 8D

    ————————————————————

    Fisher

  35. 2014-06-27 Bronx mystery creature identified Sun-Journal (Lewiston, ME), p. A6

    ————————

    Mount Vernon Monster

  36. 1973-06-29 "Monster" at pumphouse? Mt. Vernon Register-News (Mt Vernon, IL), p. 1A

  37. 1979-05-18 Peafowl or poltergeist … it’s still noisy Evening Express (Portland, ME), p. 19

    ————————

    Mount Vernon Ringtail

  38. 1928-09-11 Opossum is captured in Mt. Vernon home The Lewiston Daily Sun (Lewiston, ME), p. 4

    ————————

    Strange Animal

  39. 1933-06-05 Mystery animal drives everybody out of Sheepshead Bay restaurant Brooklyn Daily Eagle (New York, NY), p. 3

    =============================================

    Canadian Fearsome Critter Service

    =============================================