Pennsylvania

    Freshwater

    Raystown Ray

  1. 2006-05-26 Lurking in the dark of Raystown Lake [Part 1] [Part 2] The Daily Herald (Tyrone, PA), Raystown Travellers Guide, pp. 19 & 53
  2. 2008-07-24 Monster in the water? [Part 1] [Part 2] Daily American (Somerset, PA), Our Town, pp. 15 & 28
  3. 2011-10-30 Lurking in the dark of Raystown Lake Public Opinion (Chambersburg, PA), p. 5B

    ————————————————————

    Kettle Creek Monster

    West Branch Dugong, Susquehanna Seal

  4. 019-05-06 Seal of Approval: The Monster of the Susquehanna — Wayback Machine

    ————————————————————

    Fearsome Critters

    Yellow What-Is-It

    A What-Is-I?

  5. 1879-10-02 A What-Is-It? The Millheim Journal (Millheim, PA), p. 3
  6. 1879-10-04 A What-Is-It? Carbondale Advance (Carbondale, PA), p. 2
  7. 1879-10-16 A What-Is-It? The Weekly Star (Plymouth, PA), p. 6
  8. 1879-10-16 A What-Is-It? The Indiana Progress (Indiana, PA), p. 6
  9. 1879-10-16 A What-Is-It? The Indiana Progress (Indiana, PA), p. 6

    Excitement over mysterious animal

  10. 1879-12-11 Excitement over mysterious animal Helena Weekly Herald (Helena, MT), p. 6

    ————————————————————

    Huge Ape

  11. 1920-08-31 Posses in hunt for huge ape The Kalamazoo Gazette (Kalamazoo, MI), p. 19

  12. 1920-09-04 Gas to be used to kill huge ape in old mine The Coldwater Daily Reporter (Coldwater, MI), p. 1

    ————————————————————

    Paupack Creek Monster

    Paupack Creek, Pike County

  13. 1888-09-09 No title The Times (Philadelphia, PA), p. 4 NewspaperARCHIVE

  14. 1888-09-15 No title The Morning News (Savannah, GA), p. 4 NewspaperARCHIVE | Geneaology Bank

  15. 1888-09-21 A big and tough snake story Buffalo Courier (Buffalo, NY), p. 2

  16. 1888-09-24 The remarkable monster of Paupack The Hartford Courant (Hartford, CT), p. 6

  17. 1888-10-30 Found an unknown monster The Daily Journal (Logansport, IN), p. 7

  18. 1888-11-10 No title Oberlin Opinion (Oberlin, KS), p. 1

  19. 1888-11-16 Paupack Creek's monster The Plain Speaker (Hazleton, PA), p. 4

    A Pike County story

  20. 1888-10-01 A Pike County story [Part 1] [Part 2] The Freeport Bulletin (Freeport, IL), p. 3

  21. 1888-10-24 A Pike County Story Albert Lea Enterprise (Albert Lea, MN), p. 1
  22. 1888-10-24 A Pike County Story Albert Lea Enterprise (Albert Lea, MN), p. 1

  23. 1888-10-25 A Pike County story The Wahpeton Times (Wahpeton, ND),p. 6 NewspaperARCHIVE | Geneaology Bank

  24. 1888-11-28 A Pike County story The Clyde Herald (Clyde, KS), p. 3

  25. 1888-11-29 A Pike County story Burr Oak Herald (Burr Oak, KS), p. 3
  26. 1888-11-29 A Pike County story Cromwell Kansas Mirror (Armourdale, KS), p. 6

  27. 1888-12-05 A Pike County story Greenleaf Herald (Greenleaf, KS), p. 3

  28. 1890-02-21 A Pike County story Chillicothe Morning Constitution (Chillicothe, MI), p. 2
  29. 1890-02-21 A Pike County story Chillicothe Morning Constitution (Chillicothe, MI), p. 2

  30. 189002-22 A Pike County story Farmers' Alliance (Lincoln, NE), p. 4

  31. 1889-03-24 A terrible monster The Brooklyn Daily Eagle (Brooklyn, NY), p. 8

  32. 1889-04-01 A terrible monster [Part 1] [Part 2] Nashville Banner (Nashville, TN), p. 2

  33. 1889-05-13 It beats the See Serpent The Nottingham Evening Post (Nottingham, ENG), p. 2

  34. 1889-08-21 Found an unknown monster Marysville Tribune (Marysville, OH), p. 7

    Beats Rider Haggard's crabs

  35. 1888-10-14 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs The Sunday Inter Ocean (Chicago, IL), p. 19 Geneaology Bank

  36. 1888-10-25 Beats Rider Haggard's crabsThe Manitowoc Pilot (Manitowoc, WI), p. 4 Geneaology Bank

  37. 1888-11-22 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs The Clay County Sentinel (Morganville, KS), p. 3
  38. 1888-11-22 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs Lenora Record (Lenora, KS), p. 2

  39. 1888-11-23 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs Cedarville Globe (Cedarville, KS), p. 4
  40. 1888-11-23 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs The Montezuma Chief (Montezuma, KS), p. 4

  41. 1888-11-24 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs The Hill City Reveille (Hill City, KS), p. 2

  42. 1888-12-01 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs Oberlin Opinion (Oberlin, KS), p. 3

  43. 1888-12-27 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs Humboldt Independent (Humboldt, IA), p. 3

  44. 1889-01-04 Beats Rider Haggard's crabs The Weekly Sentinel (Elk Creek, NE), p. 1
  45. Beats Rider Haggard's crabs

    Beats the See Serpent

  46. 1889-03-17 Beats the See Serpent The Butte Daily Miner (Butte City, MT), p. 4 NewspaperARCHIVE
  47. 1889-03-20 Beats the See Serpent Butte Semi-weekly Miner (Butte, MT), p. 2

    The Jabberwock

  48. 1888-10-16 The Jabberwock The Evening News (Emporia, KS), p. 1

  49. 1888-10-25 The Jabberwock The Cheyenne Daily Sun (Cheyenne, WY), p. 2
  50. 1888-10-25 The Jabberwock The Cheyenne Daily Sun (Cheyenne, WY), p. 2

  51. 1888-11-01 The Jabberwock The Augusta Journal (Augusta, KS), p. 4

  52. 1888-11-01 The Jabberwock NewspaperARCHIVE | Geneaology Bank

  53. 1888-11-02 The Jabberwock Conway Springs Star (Conway Springs KS), p. 2

  54. 1888-11-03 The Jabberwock Geuda Springs Herald (Geuda Springs, KS), p. 4

  55. 1888-11-09 The Jabberwock Moline Mercury (Moline, KS), p. 2

  56. 1888-11-15 The Jabberwock The Cambridge City Tribune (Cambridge City, IN), p. 4NewspaperARCHIVE | NewspaperARCHIVE

  57. 1888-11-16 The Jabberwock The Caney Chronicle (Caney, KS), p. 4

  58. 1888-11-16 The Jabberwock The Columbian (Bloomsburg, PA), p. 4 Geneaology Bank

  59. 1888-12-27 The Jabberwock The Eudora News (Eudora, KS), p. 2

  60. 1889-01-17 The Jabberwock Indiana Democrat (Indiana, PA), p. 1

  61. 1889-04-25 The Jabberwock The Macleod Gazette (Fort MacLeod, AB), p. 1
  62. 1889-04-25 The Jabberwock The Macleod Gazette (Fort MacLeod, AB), p. 1

    ————————————————————

    Giant Snakes

    McKeesport Snake

  63. 1891-05-15 A petrified monster Santa Cruz Daily Sentinel (Santa Cruz, CA), p. 1

    Mystery Animals

    Cousin of Jersey Devil appears in York County

  64. 1910-09-10 Cousin of Jersey Devil appears in York County Gazette Bulletin (Williamsport, PA), p. 2

  65. 1910-10-02 Mysterious monster scares Pennsylvanians Oregon Sunday Journal (Portland, OR)), p. 2-3

  66. 1910-10-07 Mysterious monster scares Pennsylvanians East Oregonian (Pendleton, OR), p. 2 Chronicling America

    Bearded Janus Bug

    Oakland, Susquehanna County

  67. 1935-07-24 Strange animal has eyes to see fore and aft The Leader-Post (Regina, SK), p. 2
  68. 1935-07-24 Two-headed freak The Calgary Daily Herald (Calgary, AB), p. 2
  69. 1935-07-24 Today's Strange Story — Southern Ogopogo Nanaimo Free Press (Nanaimo, BC), p. 1
  70. 1935-07-24 Fighting reptile with two heads reported captured The Winnipeg Evening Tribune (Winnipeg, MB), p. 1
  71. 1935-07-24 Strange creature has two heads Victoria Daily Times (Victoria, BC), p. 4
  72. 1935-07-24 Sea creature has head at each end The Vancouver Sun (Vancouver, BC), p. 1
  73. 1935-07-24 2 heads eyes galore reptile is sensation The Toronto Star (Toronto, ON), p. 2
  74. 1935-07-24 Ugh! It has two heads, whiskers, scores of legs, and likes a fight Boston Evening Globe (Boston, MA), p. 2
  75. 1935-07-24 Queer creature rouses savants The Hamilton Spectator (Hamilton, ON), p. 1

  76. 1935-07-25 Heat waves spawns Bearded Janus Bug The Hartford Courant (Hartford, CT), p. 12
  77. 1935-07-25 Two-headed creature excites Susquehanna The Scranton Times (Scranton, PA), p. 10
  78. 1935-07-25 Janus-like reptile puzzles countryside Democrat and Chronicle (Rochester, NY), p. 1-7
  79. 1935-07-25 Bewhiskered reptile has two heads, legs Wilmington Morning News (Wilmington, DE), p. 1
  80. 1935-07-25 Two-headed freak stumps naturalists Atlantic City Press (Atlantic City, NJ), p. 2
  81. 1935-07-25 Two-headed freak stumps naturalists Atlantic City Press (Atlantic City, NJ), p. 2

    Carnivores

    Clearfield County Canid

  82. 1946-12-10 Is it a Timber Wolf or is it a Coyote? Lewiston Evening Journal (Lewiston, ME), p. 8

    Nicholson White Tiger

  83. 1986-07-28 Tiger still enjoying freedom [Part 1] [Part 2] The Scranton Times (Scranton, PA), pp. 3 & 8

  84. 1986-07-29 Search fails to locate Bengal Tiger Citizens' Voice (Wilkes-Barre, PA), p. 3
  85. 1986-07-29 Tiger eludes trackers [Part 1] [Part 2] The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, PA), pp. 1A & 10A
  86. 1986-07-29 Tiger sighting draws attention to tiny town The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, PA), p. 10A
  87. 1986-07-29 Tiger hunted near city; skepticism grows [Part 1] [Part 2] The Tribune (Scranton, PA), pp. 1 & 10
  88. 1986-07-29 Ready if needed The Tribune (Scranton, PA), p. 10
  89. 1986-07-29 If there is a Tiger in woods, it is nothing to mess with The Tribune (Scranton, PA), p. 10
  90. 1986-07-29 Big cat probably native puma, expert believes The Danville News (Danville, PA), p. 11
  91. 1986-07-29 Police Probing Report Tiger's Owner Is Known [Part 1] [Part 2] The Scranton Times (Scranton, PA), pp. 3 & 12

  92. 1986-07-30 Tiger-Sighting Reports Tail Off As Police Paws in Their Quest The Scranton Times (Scranton, PA), p. 4
  93. 1986-07-30 Trooper says sightings reports getting ridiculous [Part 1] [Part 2] The Times Leader (Wilkes-Barre, PA), pp. 3A & 7A
  94. 1986-07-30 Caller claims roaming tiger is escaped pet The Morning Call, First Edition (Allentown, PA), p. A4
  95. 1986-07-30 Caller claims roaming tiger is escaped pet The Morning Call, Fourth Edition (Allentown, PA), p. A4
  96. 1986-07-30 Tiger may be escaped pet Centre Daily Times (State College, PA), p. A6

    Thing of Sheep Hill

  97. 1945-11-14 4 injured hunting Penn. mystery beast The Lewiston Daily Sun (Lewiston, ME), p. 7
  98. 1945-11-14 Mysterious beast sought by posse in Kleystone State Biddeford Daily Journal (Biddeford, ME), p. 1

  99. 1916-02-03 Again in terror of strange animal Meyersdale Republican (Meyersdale, PA), p. 1

  100. 1930-08-23 Today’s Oddest News — Coyote roams about Philadelphia docks Edmonton Bulletin (Edmonton, AB), p. 1
  101. 1930-09-15 "Whatisit," new animal puzzle The Leader-Post (Regina, SK), p. 14

  102. 1946-12-12 Strange animals everywhere The Gazette (Montreal, QC), p. 17

  103. 1955-03-02 Black Panther Prowling In Nev Castle District The News-Herald, p. 1
  104. 1955-03-02 Strange Animal Is Puzzling Officers Hinton Daily News, p. 1
  105. 1955-03-03 Report wild animal near Nev Castle Greenville Daily Advocate, p. 11
  106. 1955-03-03 Police scour hillsides for 'big cat [Banner] [Part 1] [Part 2] The Pittsburgh Press, pp. 1 & 8

  107. 1986-07-30 'Wacko's stalk mysterious tiger The Advocate (Red Deer, AB), p. 8D

    Pet Lions

  108. 1965-10-06 Sautfer gets new Lion cub from 'friend' The Scranton Times (Scranton, PA), P. 32

    Paramormal

    Ghost Cow

  109. 1896-08-08 Ghost of a Cow with severed head [Part 1] [Part 2] The World (New York, NY), p. 21

    =============================================

    Canadian Fearsome Critter Service

    =============================================